CRC Press has published a new book which explores the ethical dilemmas facing veterinary surgeons today, and challenges a lot of the current orthodoxy.

With contributions from 26 leading lights edited by Tanya Stephens, Eddie Clutton, Polly Taylor and Kathy L. Murphy, 'Veterinary Controversies and Ethical Dilemmas - Provocative Reflections on Clinical Practice' is pitched as being designed to 'stimulate undergraduate thought and discussion', and as a reference for practitioners coming to terms with life in a post-truth era.  

That, however, is a massive undersell of the importance and value of this book, which should be required reading for everyone in the profession; not just veterinary surgeons, but nurses, regulators and RCVS Councillors, teachers, pharma companies, practice managers (including corporates) and veterinary receptionists, all of whom would benefit from an informed understanding of the most important issues facing the profession today. 

There are too many subject areas in the book to list here, but some of the most eye-catching include the questions of:

  • Overdiagnosis and treatment, including the harms of overdiagnosis
  • The ethics of surgery which might better be described as experimentation
  • Evidence-free veterinary medicine, such as alternative medicine, supplements and 'therapeutic' foods. 
  • Anthropomorphism - the rise of the 'pet parent' and some of the harms of anthropomorphism
  • Corporatisation, veterinary education, euthanasia and more ... 

It would be wrong to say that the veterinary profession is at a turning point. It has already turned. The question is whether it's heading in the right direction. This book provides a timely opportunity for everyone to reflect on that.

More practically, general practitioners should find this book hugely helpful in informing and shaping their own ethical positions on a variety of subjects, and to be able to express them to clients with more confidence, potentially with a real benefit to animal welfare. 

The book is available direct from the publisher: https://www.routledge.com/Veterinary-Controversies-and-Ethical-Dilemmas-Provocative-Reflections-/Clutton-Murphy-Stephens-Taylor/p/book/9781032579863

Or from Amazon and all good bookstores: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Veterinary-Controversies-Ethical-Dilemmas-Provocative/dp/1032579862 

Photo: A gripping read.

PS: Whilst you're here, take a moment to see our latest job opportunities for vets.